News for Tool Hire, Equipment Hire & Plant Hire and Rental Professionals

AI pros and cons

6 August 2025

AI pros and cons

The impact that AI (artificial intelligence) is having on individuals and society is one of the most frequently discussed topics and it can clearly have positive and negative results.

The subject cropped up during a recent conversation I had with Neil Holloway, managing director of the Wilson Brook Consulting executive recruitment business which works with clients in diverse sectors including hire, construction and engineering, giving the company a broad market perspective.

He believes organisations are looking at how the technology can support them, not just for automating repetitive tasks cost-effectively, but also because it can be so difficult finding good people when so many have removed themselves from the labour pool. (Indeed, figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) estimate that some 923,000 16 to 24-year-olds were not in education, employment or training - Neet - in the first three months of 2025.)

“Ultimately most firms will always need people somewhere in their operations,” said Neil. “It’s a case of finding the right blend of technology and human interactions.

“Monotonous, mundane tasks perhaps lend themselves better to automation, whereas our recruitment work is generally undertaken at a senior level and there will always be a need for an MD, sales director, operations director and a talented management team within any operation.

“I see AI as more of an opportunity than a threat. It depends on where you stand in the hierarchy of things.”

Neil certainly embraces AI himself for certain tasks, sometimes using ChatGPT, for example, to generate initial data and findings that he can then check and fine-tune himself. He employs other programs to automatically take notes during conversations in a way that is tailored to specific requirements rather than just taking a long, bland transcript.

However, other applications might be less helpful.

“I’ve heard of software whose developers claim it can act as an AI recruiter! A candidate would interact with it over a Teams or Zoom meeting and the system is said to be intelligent enough to adapt its responses to answers given. But that would completely remove the personal touch – and how many people would really want to have that kind of ‘conversation’?”

I’ve posted previously on the blog about the use of AI by job applicants to generate their CVs and letters of application, and the disadvantages it can bring. You can read that here.

“It’s also possible to feed CVs and interview notes into an AI platform and ask it to select the best candidate. However, accuracy surely depends on the quality of the input information, and while it might be useful as an initial screening, would you really trust the automatically generated results more than human judgement?”

● Subscribe free to the blog here to receive regular news updates for tool hire and plant hire professionals.


Subscribe

I am constantly adding new content. If you subscribe FREE using the form below, I'll send you my weekly bulletin summarising the latest hire industry stories - and I'll also send you a PDF of 10 fascinating interviews with national and independent hirers, giving their views about business and their secrets of success!